Tag: Early Career

  • Why Does Everything Take Me So Long as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional?

    Why Does Everything Take Me So Long as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional?

    You watch a colleague finish an assessment, write their notes and move on.

    You are still checking the record.

    You are thinking about whether you asked everything you needed to ask.

    You are trying to decide what matters most.

    Then you start documenting and wonder whether you have written too much, too little, or missed something important.

    By lunchtime, you already feel behind.

    And one thought keeps returning:

    Why does everything take me so long?

    For many newly qualified healthcare professionals, this is one of the least discussed parts of starting work.

    You may have expected to feel inexperienced.

    You may not have expected how much longer ordinary tasks would seem to take.

    It is easy to assume this means you have poor time management.

    Often, the problem is more specific: one part of the work is still taking more thought, searching, repetition or documentation than it eventually will.

    In brief

    Early in practice, more of the job still requires conscious thought.

    You are learning:

    • what information matters most;
    • how local systems work;
    • where to find things;
    • what “enough” looks like;
    • what usually happens next;
    • and which parts of the job become easier through repetition.

    That does not mean efficiency is unimportant.

    It means that trying to “work faster” is often the wrong starting point.

    A better question is:

    Where is the time actually going?

    The goal is not speed for its own sake.

    It is professional fluency: becoming more efficient because your thinking, routines and familiarity with the work are developing.

    Why does everything take longer when you are new?

    When something is unfamiliar, it demands more attention.

    You may need to consciously think through steps that gradually become easier with experience.

    • What information do I need?
    • Where is it recorded?
    • What should I do next?
    • Who needs to know?
    • What needs documenting?
    • What happens after this?

    None of those questions is unreasonable.

    The difficulty is that answering them repeatedly takes time and mental capacity.

    As routines become more familiar, some of that effort reduces.

    You know where information is likely to be.

    You recognise common situations sooner.

    You become clearer about which parts of the task need detail and which do not.

    You begin anticipating what comes next instead of discovering it after every step.

    That is one reason work can gradually begin to feel smoother.

    Early in the first year, unfamiliarity itself may be the biggest challenge.

    Later in early practice, the difficulty may shift towards handling greater complexity, interruptions and multiple competing demands efficiently.

    Want more practical guidance for early healthcare practice?

    Core & Oak explores the parts of professional practice that are often expected but rarely explained clearly — including workload, professional judgement, communication, confidence and career development.

    Join the Core & Oak mailing list for new articles and practical resources.

    Efficiency is not the same as prioritisation

    These two problems can feel similar, but they are not the same.

    Prioritisation is about deciding what should happen first.

    Efficiency is about understanding why the work itself is taking as long as it is.

    You can know what should happen next and still find that individual assessments, documentation or routine processes take longer than expected.

    If the main difficulty is deciding what should happen first when several demands compete, read How to Prioritise When Everything Feels Important as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional.

    This article is about something different:

    Why does the work itself still feel so effortful?

    Where is the time actually going?

    Before trying to become faster, diagnose the bottleneck.

    A useful way to do this is to look at five places where time can disappear:

    Thinking

    Finding

    Doing

    Documenting

    Switching

    The point is not to decide which one you are “bad at”.

    It is to work out what kind of problem you are actually trying to solve.

    Infographic showing five places time can be lost in early healthcare practice: thinking, finding, doing, documenting and switching, with reflective questions for each.

    1. Thinking

    Are you spending a long time deciding what information means or what to do with it?

    Some of this is developmental.

    You may still be building familiarity with common presentations, decisions or professional situations.

    What matters is whether the same kinds of decisions gradually become easier to organise.

    A useful question is:

    What is taking me longest — gathering information, interpreting it, or deciding what to do next?

    If the issue is interpretation, compare your reasoning with someone more experienced.

    Ask:

    What are they noticing first?

    What information are they giving less weight to?

    What helps them decide they have enough information to act?

    If the difficult part is making sense of information and deciding what it means, How to Explain Your Clinical Reasoning Clearly as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional explores that in more depth.

    Try this: choose one recurring type of decision and compare how you approach it with a more experienced colleague.

    2. Finding

    How much time do you spend looking for things?

    Policies.

    Equipment.

    Phone numbers.

    Referral forms.

    Patient information.

    The right person to contact.

    Local systems are often invisible to people who already know them.

    A surprising amount of early-career efficiency comes from simply learning how the organisation works.

    What once required ten minutes of searching may eventually take thirty seconds because you know where to look.

    That is not a small gain.

    Across a working day, it matters.

    Try this: keep a short list of the systems, contacts or resources you repeatedly need until they become familiar.

    3. Doing

    Some tasks are slow because they are still unfamiliar.

    Assessment.

    Treatment.

    Medication processes.

    Equipment fitting.

    Patient education.

    Setting up a clinic.

    Completing a referral.

    Tasks often become smoother through repetition.

    But repetition alone is not always enough.

    Sometimes a task remains slow because you are using an unnecessarily complicated sequence, repeating steps, or unsure which parts matter most.

    Specific feedback can help.

    The useful question is not:

    “Am I too slow?”

    It is:

    “Which part of this task could become simpler or more consistent?”

    Try this: identify one repeated task and ask for feedback on one specific aspect of how you complete it.

    If you genuinely need another person’s judgement before you can progress, that is not simply an efficiency problem. How to Ask for Help Without Feeling Incompetent explores how to make that request clearly.

    4. Documenting

    Documentation is a common place for time to disappear.

    You may feel pressure to record everything because you are not yet sure which details are essential.

    Ask yourself:

    Am I documenting what matters?

    Am I repeating information that already exists elsewhere?

    Am I spending too long trying to make the wording perfect?

    Am I clear about what my organisation expects?

    Good documentation needs to be accurate, relevant and defensible.

    That does not automatically mean long.

    Sometimes the development is not “write faster”.

    It is learning to distinguish between:

    important detail

    and

    additional detail that does not change the record or plan.

    If repeated checking or rewriting is driven mainly by anxiety or a need for reassurance, How Much Anxiety Is Normal in a Newly Qualified Healthcare Role? explores that pattern separately.

    Try this: compare one of your routine notes with a strong local example and identify where you may be adding detail that is not changing the meaning.

    5. Switching

    Sometimes the task itself is not particularly slow.

    The problem is that you rarely finish anything in one go.

    You begin documenting.

    Someone asks a question.

    You answer a call.

    You check another patient.

    You return to the note.

    Then you need to remember where you were.

    Healthcare involves unavoidable interruption.

    But repeated switching has a cost.

    Sometimes efficiency improves because you become better at completing a small unit of work before opening another, where the setting allows.

    The gain is not necessarily faster performance.

    It is less restarting.

    Try this: notice one point in your day where you could finish a short task before moving to the next interruption.

    Is being slow actually a problem?

    Sometimes, no.

    Taking longer may be entirely appropriate if:

    • the task is unfamiliar;
    • you are learning a new system;
    • the situation is genuinely complex;
    • you are appropriately checking something important;
    • or you have not yet repeated the task enough for it to feel routine.

    That is different from a pattern that remains unnecessarily time-consuming.

    It may be worth looking more closely if:

    • familiar tasks remain equally difficult over time;
    • documentation regularly takes much longer than expected;
    • you repeatedly duplicate work;
    • you lose time because you are unsure when something is complete;
    • perfectionism makes ordinary tasks difficult to finish;
    • or you regularly cannot explain where your time has gone.

    The aim is not to label yourself as “too slow”.

    It is to identify what kind of slowness you are dealing with.

    How can I get faster at work without rushing?

    Start with the bottleneck.

    If the problem is thinking, compare how you approach the decision with someone more experienced.

    If it is finding, build familiarity with local systems.

    If it is doing, practise the task and ask for specific feedback.

    If it is documenting, review examples of clear, proportionate records.

    If it is switching, look for opportunities to complete one small unit of work before reopening another.

    Do not try to improve everything at once.

    Choose one repeated task.

    Identify what is slowing it down.

    Make one change.

    Then see whether it helps.

    You are not trying to prove that you are efficient.

    You are testing what makes one part of your work more fluent.

    A worked example: documentation

    Imagine a newly qualified physiotherapist who regularly spends 20–25 minutes documenting a routine assessment.

    A colleague completes similar notes much more quickly.

    The obvious conclusion is:

    “I need to write faster.”

    But that may not be the real problem.

    Looking more closely, the new graduate notices that they:

    • repeat information already recorded elsewhere;
    • write long descriptions before reaching the important clinical point;
    • stop repeatedly to decide how to phrase things;
    • have no consistent structure;
    • and reopen the note several times because they are unsure whether it is complete.

    The development plan is not simply:

    “Be quicker.”

    It might be:

    Review a few examples of good documentation.

    Identify the information that genuinely affects the record or plan.

    Agree a clear structure.

    Use that structure consistently.

    Then review one note with a supervisor.

    The aim is to become more selective and fluent, not less thorough.

    What if the real problem is the system rather than me?

    This distinction matters.

    Sometimes you are not slow.

    The system is slow.

    A poor IT system may add several minutes to every task.

    Equipment may be difficult to access.

    Processes may duplicate work.

    Travel expectations may be unrealistic.

    Staffing may be reduced.

    Referral routes may be unnecessarily complicated.

    If several people are struggling to complete the expected workload, it is worth asking whether this is really an individual efficiency problem.

    Do not automatically turn a service problem into a personal productivity problem.

    Sometimes the right question is not:

    “How do I work faster?”

    It is:

    “What is making this work unnecessarily difficult to complete?”

    The hidden curriculum: do not copy visible speed without invisible judgement

    One of the risks early in practice is copying what experienced practitioners appear to do.

    You see someone complete an assessment quickly.

    So you shorten yours.

    You see their documentation is brief.

    So you make yours brief.

    But you cannot always see the reasoning underneath.

    An experienced practitioner may be brief because they already know which information matters.

    A new practitioner may be brief because they are trying to save time.

    Those are not the same thing.

    Do not copy visible speed without understanding the invisible judgement underneath it.

    Speed is often the result of fluency.

    It is not a substitute for it.

    The goal is professional fluency

    Professional fluency can look like:

    • knowing where to find what you need;
    • recognising familiar patterns earlier;
    • spending less time on information that does not affect the task;
    • using reliable routines;
    • documenting clearly without unnecessary detail;
    • anticipating what happens next;
    • and recovering more easily when work is interrupted.

    This usually develops gradually.

    You may not notice it happening.

    Then something that once took thirty minutes takes fifteen.

    A process that once felt confusing becomes routine.

    You realise you no longer have to consciously think about every step.

    That is progress.

    Try this in practice

    Choose one repeated task that regularly feels slower than it should.

    Ask:

    Where is the time going?

    Is it:

    Thinking?

    Finding?

    Doing?

    Documenting?

    Switching?

    Then choose one change you can test over the next week.

    Do not ask:

    “How can I become faster at everything?”

    Ask:

    “What would make this one part of my work more fluent?”

    The Core & Oak perspective

    Early-career practice can make speed feel like evidence of competence.

    It is not that simple.

    As familiarity, judgement and routines develop, many parts of practice should gradually become more efficient.

    But the goal is not to imitate visible speed.

    It is to develop the judgement, routines and familiarity underneath it.

    Sustainable efficiency comes from:

    • repeated practice;
    • selective attention;
    • clear systems;
    • useful feedback;
    • and knowing what actually matters.

    Not from rushing.

    The aim is not simply to work faster.

    It is to become increasingly fluent in the work you are responsible for.

    Continue exploring early practice

    How to Prioritise When Everything Feels Important as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional
    If the difficulty is deciding what needs attention first when several demands compete.

    How to Explain Your Clinical Reasoning Clearly as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional
    If making sense of information and reaching a clear judgement is what takes most of your time.

    How to Ask for Help Without Feeling Incompetent
    If you know you need another person’s input but hesitate to ask.

    About the author

    Dr Michael McCluskey is a Chartered Physiotherapist and Senior Fellow of the Higher Education Academy, with experience across clinical practice, healthcare education, programme leadership, assessment and curriculum development.

    He founded Core & Oak to create evidence-informed professional development that makes the hidden expectations of healthcare practice clearer.

    Professional education disclaimer

    This article provides general professional education. It does not provide individual clinical, employment, legal or other professional advice.

    Healthcare professionals should work within their scope of practice and follow the policies, procedures, supervision arrangements and professional standards relevant to their profession, role and organisation.

    Editorial and evidence standards

    Core & Oak content is developed using the following principles:

    • Content is written or reviewed by a suitably qualified professional.
    • Professional and regulatory sources are prioritised where relevant.
    • Research evidence is interpreted cautiously and within its limitations.
    • Practical guidance is distinguished from individual clinical advice.
    • Uncertainty, contextual variation and system pressures are acknowledged.
    • Articles are periodically reviewed and updated.
    • Commercial links are included only where the resource is relevant to the reader’s identified need.

    Further reading

    Brennan, N., Burns, L., Mattick, K., Mitchell, A., Henderson, T., Walker, K. and Gale, T. (2024). How prepared are newly qualified allied health professionals for practice in the UK? A systematic review. BMJ Open, 14, e081518.

    Offiah, G. and Doherty, E. (2018). Tricks of the trade: time management tips for newly qualified doctors. Postgraduate Medical Journal, 94(1109), 159–161.

    Writing for the role: A qualitative exploration of new graduate physiotherapists’ transition to practice of clinical documentation. Physiotherapy Theory and Practice.

  • How to Speak Up at Work When Everyone Else Seems More Experienced

    How to Speak Up at Work When Everyone Else Seems More Experienced

    You are sitting in a team discussion.

    Several experienced colleagues are talking about a patient you have been working with.

    You have noticed something that might be relevant.

    You think about saying it.

    Then someone more senior speaks. The conversation moves on.

    You tell yourself:

    They probably already know.

    Maybe it is obvious.

    Maybe I have misunderstood.

    Maybe this is not really my place to say.

    So you stay quiet.

    For newly qualified healthcare professionals, speaking up can feel harder than it looks.

    The difficulty is not always knowing what to say.

    Sometimes it is deciding whether what you have noticed is important enough to contribute when everyone around you seems more experienced.

    That is part of the transition into professional practice.

    You are no longer only expected to observe and learn.

    You are beginning to contribute.

    In brief

    You do not need to be the most experienced person in the room to have something useful to add.

    Useful professional contribution might involve:

    • sharing information others may not have;
    • adding a perspective from your assessment or profession;
    • bringing the patient’s perspective into the discussion;
    • asking a useful question;
    • identifying a practical issue;
    • or highlighting something that could affect the plan.

    Speaking up does not mean pretending to know more than you do.

    It means recognising when something you know, notice or question could help the team.

    In this article, speaking up means contributing appropriately to everyday professional discussions. That is different from formal Freedom to Speak Up or whistleblowing processes, although some situations may move into raising or escalating a concern.

    How do I know when it is worth saying something?

    You do not need to comment on everything.

    A useful question is:

    Am I adding something that helps the team?

    That might be:

    Information
    Something the team may not know.

    Perspective
    Something from your profession, assessment or interaction with the patient.

    A useful question
    Something that could clarify the plan.

    Something that may affect what happens next
    A practical issue, patient preference or concern that changes the picture.

    If you are adding one of those things, there may be value in contributing.

    The aim is not to prove that you have an opinion.

    It is to help the conversation move forward.

    Want more practical guidance for early professional practice?

    Core & Oak explores the parts of healthcare practice that are often expected but rarely explained clearly such as professional judgement, communication, uncertainty, accountability and career development.

    Join the Core & Oak mailing list for new articles and practical resources.

    Why does this feel difficult when you are newly qualified?

    Healthcare is hierarchical.

    Some colleagues have more experience, specialist expertise or formal responsibility than you do.

    That matters.

    But hierarchy can also create an assumption:

    “If this was important, somebody more experienced would already have mentioned it.”

    That is not always true.

    Different professionals see different parts of the picture.

    You may have spent more time with the patient.

    You may have information from an assessment that has not yet reached the wider team.

    A patient may have told you something they did not tell somebody else.

    Your profession may notice something that another profession would not naturally prioritise.

    Research on speaking up and psychological safety in healthcare suggests that hierarchy, team culture and how receptive colleagues appear can all influence whether people feel able to contribute.

    So the question is not simply:

    “Am I experienced enough to say this?”

    A better question is:

    “Could this help the team understand the situation or make the next decision?”

    What can useful contribution sound like?

    Speaking up does not always mean challenging somebody.

    Often, it is much more ordinary.

    You might say:

    “One thing I noticed was…”

    “The patient mentioned something that might affect the plan…”

    “Can I check how this fits with…?”

    “I wonder whether we also need to consider…”

    “One practical issue might be…”

    These statements do not claim authority you do not have.

    They make it easier for other people to understand what you are adding.

    Before speaking, it can help to organise three things:

    What have I noticed?

    Why might it matter?

    What do I want the team to do with that information?

    Sometimes you are simply informing.

    Sometimes you are asking.

    Sometimes you are suggesting.

    Sometimes you are inviting the team to think again.

    If the difficult part is not deciding whether to contribute but explaining the reasoning behind what you think, How to Explain Your Clinical Reasoning Clearly as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional explores that skill in more detail.

    Core & Oak infographic showing a four-step activity for developing professional voice: notice, check, contribute and reflect.

    A worked example

    Imagine a newly qualified occupational therapist attending an MDT discussion about a patient who may be discharged home.

    The conversation is focused on mobility, medication and transport.

    The OT has spent time with the patient that morning.

    During the assessment, the patient repeatedly said they were worried about managing meals alone when they returned home.

    The OT hesitates.

    Everyone else seems focused on whether discharge can happen today.

    They could assume somebody else will deal with the concern.

    Instead, they say:

    “One thing I wanted to add is that she has raised concerns several times about managing meals on her own. I’m not sure that is reflected in the current discharge plan.”

    The OT has not solved the whole problem.

    They have not claimed that discharge should be stopped.

    They have contributed information the wider team may need.

    That is professional participation.

    Speaking up happens outside formal meetings

    Professional voice is not only about MDT meetings.

    It can happen during handover, ward rounds, community team discussions, supervision, case conferences, school meetings, clinics or informal conversations with colleagues.

    A community practitioner might point out that a planned visit conflicts with a carer’s availability.

    A clinician in private practice might raise a concern about how follow-up has been arranged.

    A practitioner working in a school might highlight information from teaching staff that affects the current plan.

    Contribution often happens in ordinary moments.

    What if somebody disagrees with me?

    Speaking up does not mean your view will be accepted.

    Nor should it.

    Someone else may have information you do not have.

    A more experienced practitioner may interpret the situation differently.

    Your suggestion may not be taken forward.

    That does not automatically mean it was wrong to contribute.

    Contributing is not the same as winning the discussion.

    You might respond:

    “That makes sense. The part I was mainly concerned about was…”

    or:

    “Can you help me understand what makes that less important in this situation?”

    That allows you to stay involved without becoming defensive.

    It also gives you access to how somebody else is reasoning.

    Speaking up becomes more difficult when the conversation moves from adding information to disagreement, challenge or raising something uncomfortable. Those situations often require more deliberate communication skills, particularly where hierarchy or pressure are involved.

    Speaking up is not always the same as asking for help or escalating

    Sometimes you are contributing to a discussion.

    Sometimes you need another person’s judgement because you are unsure how to proceed.

    And sometimes you have identified a concern that means somebody else needs to know, review, decide or act.

    Those are different situations.

    If you need support because you are uncertain what to do, How to Ask for Help Without Feeling Incompetent explores how to organise that request.

    If the issue involves risk or whether responsibility needs to widen, When Should I Escalate a Concern as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional? explores that in more detail.

    Where there is an immediate or material safety concern, your professional responsibilities and local escalation procedures take priority over the conversational approaches discussed here.

    The skill is recognising what kind of conversation you are having.

    What if I am worried about being wrong?

    You will sometimes raise something that turns out not to matter.

    You may suggest an option that is not appropriate.

    You may ask a question whose answer seems obvious once someone explains it.

    That is part of developing professionally.

    If you stay silent until you are completely certain that your contribution is correct, you also lose opportunities to participate, test your thinking and learn from the response.

    The goal is not to speak for the sake of speaking.

    It is to become increasingly able to recognise when your information, perspective or question could help.

    What if nobody responds?

    Sometimes you make a point and the conversation moves on.

    First, consider whether your contribution was clear.

    You might say:

    “Can I just check whether that changes the plan at all?”

    or:

    “I want to make sure that point has not been missed.”

    If it is simply an observation or suggestion, it may be reasonable to revisit it later or accept that the team has reached a different judgement.

    If the issue becomes a material safety concern, it has moved beyond everyday contribution and should be managed through the appropriate escalation route.

    The hidden curriculum: contribution is noticed

    Newly qualified practitioners often assume they are mainly being judged on what they know.

    But colleagues also notice how you participate.

    Do you bring relevant information?

    Do you listen?

    Can you ask useful questions?

    Can you disagree respectfully?

    Can you recognise when somebody else has better information?

    Can you contribute without overstating what you know?

    These expectations are rarely written down.

    But they shape how people experience working with you.

    Professional credibility is not built by speaking the most. It is built by making useful contributions consistently.

    Try this in practice

    Before your next team discussion, handover or MDT, identify one thing you might usefully contribute.

    Ask yourself:

    • Am I adding information, perspective, a useful question or something that may affect the plan?
    • If it becomes relevant, how could I say it clearly?
    • What would I want the team to do with that information?

    Afterwards, reflect briefly:

    What made me speak — or stay quiet?

    How did I phrase it?

    How did the team respond?

    What would I do differently next time?

    The aim is not to make yourself speak more often.

    It is to become clearer about when your contribution may be useful.

    The Core & Oak perspective

    Early in your career, it can feel safer to wait until you are more experienced before contributing.

    But experience develops partly through participation.

    You learn by hearing how other people think.

    You learn by testing your own observations.

    You learn when somebody agrees with you.

    And you learn when they do not.

    You do not need to sound senior.

    You do not need to have the final answer.

    You need to recognise when something you know, notice or question could help the team.

    Professional contribution does not begin when somebody gives you a leadership title.

    It begins when you start using your professional voice thoughtfully.

    Want to develop these conversations further?

    Speaking up in everyday practice is one part of professional communication.

    It becomes more difficult when the conversation involves disagreement, hierarchy, uncertainty or something that feels uncomfortable to raise.

    Professional Communication in Everyday Healthcare explores these situations in more depth through realistic examples and practical frameworks for difficult conversations, asking for support, escalation, feedback and communicating under pressure.

    Access the course →

    Further Reading

    Edmondson, A.C. (2003). Speaking Up in the Operating Room: How Team Leaders Promote Learning in Interdisciplinary Action Teams. Journal of Management Studies, 40(6), 1419–1452. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-6486.00386

    Morrison, E.W. (2014). Employee Voice and Silence. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 1, 173–197. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-031413-091328

    Mansour, M. and Mattukoyya, R. (2019). Development of assertive communication skills in nursing preceptorship programmes: a qualitative insight from newly qualified nurses. Nursing Management, 26(4), 29–35. https://doi.org/10.7748/nm.2019.e185

    O’Donovan, R. and McAuliffe, E. (2020). A systematic review exploring the content and outcomes of interventions to improve psychological safety, speaking up and voice behaviour. BMC Health Services Research, 20, 101. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-020-4931-2

    Kane, J., Munn, L., Kane, S.F. and Srulovici, E. (2023). Defining Speaking Up in the Healthcare System: a Systematic Review. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 38, 3406–3413. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-023-08322-0

    About the author

    Dr Michael McCluskey is a Chartered Physiotherapist and Senior Fellow of the Higher Education Academy, with experience across clinical practice, healthcare education, programme leadership, assessment and curriculum development.

    He founded Core & Oak to create evidence-informed professional development that makes the hidden expectations of healthcare practice clearer.

    Professional education disclaimer

    This article provides general professional education. It does not provide individual clinical, employment, legal or other professional advice.

    Healthcare professionals should work within their scope of practice and follow the professional standards, incident-reporting procedures, duty-of-candour requirements, policies and processes relevant to their profession, role, organisation and jurisdiction.

    Where there is an immediate patient-safety concern, practitioners should follow the appropriate local escalation or emergency process.

  • How to Receive Feedback Without Becoming Defensive as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional

    How to Receive Feedback Without Becoming Defensive as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional

    You have just finished explaining what you did.

    Your senior colleague listens and says:

    “Next time, I think you need to…”

    Before they finish, you can already feel yourself preparing a response.

    But I did think about that.

    They don’t know everything that happened.

    That’s not really fair.

    You start explaining why you made the decision.

    The more you explain, the more it sounds as though you are arguing.

    Later, you replay the conversation and wonder:

    Why did I get so defensive?

    Receiving feedback can feel surprisingly personal when you are newly qualified.

    You have spent years being assessed. You are trying to establish yourself as a credible professional. When someone questions something you have done, it can easily feel as though they are questioning whether you are good enough to be there.

    But feedback about something you did is not automatically a judgement about who you are as a practitioner.

    Learning to separate those two things is an important part of professional development.

    In Brief

    Feeling defensive when you receive feedback is not unusual.

    Feeling defensive is also not the same as responding defensively.

    The professional skill is creating enough space between the feeling and your response.

    When feedback catches you off guard:

    Pause. Clarify. Consider. Act.

    You do not have to agree with every piece of feedback you receive.

    But it helps to understand it before you decide whether it is useful.

    The goal is not:

    “How do I prove I was right?”

    A better question is:

    “What, if anything, can I learn or change from this?”

    Professional credibility includes how you respond when your judgement is challenged.

    Making your reasoning visible allows other people to question it; learning to respond to that challenge is the next part of professional development.

    Why can feedback feel so personal after qualifying?

    For much of your training, feedback was closely connected to assessment.

    Someone observed what you did.

    They judged it against a standard.

    Sometimes that judgement affected whether you passed.

    It is understandable if some of that feeling follows you into professional practice.

    So:

    “Your handover could have been clearer.”

    can quickly become:

    “I’m bad at handover.”

    and then:

    “They don’t think I’m competent.”

    Those are three different statements.

    If feedback quickly becomes evidence in your mind that you do not really belong, Why Do New Healthcare Professionals Often Feel Like Imposters? → explores why that reaction can be so strong early in practice.

    Useful feedback should help you examine your practice – something you did, decided or communicated.

    It should not require you to turn one event into a judgement about your entire professional identity.

    That distinction is especially important early in your career, when confidence and professional identity are still developing.

    Core & Oak infographic showing feedback about a handover being reframed into the question, “Which part was unclear, and what would you expect next time?”

    How to stop becoming defensive when you receive feedback

    1. Pause before explaining

    A defensive response often begins with:

    “Yes, but…”

    Sometimes there genuinely is important context the other person does not know.

    But if you explain it before you have understood their point, it may sound as though your main aim is to prove that you were right.

    Try:

    “Okay. Can you talk me through what you noticed?”

    Or:

    “Can you explain which part concerned you?”

    That gives you a moment to understand the feedback before deciding whether further explanation is needed.

    2. Clarify what they actually mean

    Not all feedback is specific enough to be useful.

    “You need to be more confident.”

    “Your documentation needs to improve.”

    “You need to communicate more clearly.”

    What exactly should change?

    Ask:

    “Can you give me an example?”

    “Which part would you have approached differently?”

    “What would you expect to see next time?”

    Specific feedback is easier to act on than a broad judgement.

    3. Consider it without automatically accepting it

    Feedback is information.

    It is not automatically correct simply because it comes from someone more experienced.

    Another practitioner may have noticed something important.

    They may also have different information, preferences or expectations.

    Ask yourself:

    • Is there something here I had not considered?
    • Is this a pattern I have heard before?
    • What part of the feedback is useful?
    • Is there relevant context that needs explaining?
    • Would I do anything differently next time?

    You can take feedback seriously without treating every comment as unquestionable.

    4. Decide what happens next

    Useful engagement with feedback should eventually lead somewhere.

    That might be:

    “Next time I’ll state the main concern at the beginning of the handover.”

    Or:

    “I’ll check the local guidance because I wasn’t aware of that expectation.”

    Or even:

    “I’ve thought about it and I’d still make the same decision, but I can see that I need to explain my reasoning more clearly.”

    The important shift is from defending your identity to evaluating your practice.

    A worked example

    A newly qualified healthcare professional gives a detailed handover about a patient.

    Afterwards, their supervisor says:

    “There was a lot of useful information there, but I wasn’t clear what you were actually concerned about.”

    Their immediate reaction is:

    But I gave you all the information.

    They could respond:

    “I did explain everything that had happened.”

    That may be true.

    But it does not help them understand the feedback.

    Instead, they ask:

    “Can you tell me where you felt the main concern became unclear?”

    The supervisor explains that the key change in the patient’s presentation appeared quite late in the handover.

    The practitioner thinks about this and responds:

    “That makes sense. I was trying to be thorough, but I can see that the important change got buried. Next time I’ll lead with the concern and then give the supporting detail.”

    Notice what they have not done.

    They have not agreed that the whole handover was poor.

    They have not pretended the feedback felt comfortable.

    They have identified one useful change.

    That is a professional response to feedback.

    The hidden curriculum: people notice how you respond when challenged

    Early in your career, it is easy to assume professional credibility comes from demonstrating that your decisions were correct.

    But colleagues are also learning something else:

    What happens when your judgement is questioned?

    Can you listen?

    Can you ask for clarification?

    Can you explain your reasoning without becoming combative?

    Can you recognise when somebody else has noticed something useful?

    Can you change your practice when appropriate?

    These expectations are not always made explicit in day-to-day practice.

    But they influence how colleagues experience working with you.

    Being open to feedback does not mean becoming passive or unquestioning.

    It means being able to examine your practice without treating every challenge as a threat.

    What if the feedback feels unfair?

    Not all feedback is good feedback.

    It can be vague.

    Poorly timed.

    Inconsistent.

    Delivered badly.

    Or based on incomplete information.

    You are allowed to ask questions.

    For example:

    “I’d like to understand the specific concern.”

    “Can we talk through what you would expect me to do differently?”

    You can also take time to reflect, discuss it in supervision or seek another perspective before deciding what you think.

    And there is an important boundary here.

    Receiving feedback professionally does not mean accepting disrespectful, discriminatory or inappropriate behaviour simply because somebody describes it as feedback.

    The aim is thoughtful engagement, not unquestioning compliance.

    A useful question after difficult feedback

    Instead of asking:

    “Was the other person right?”

    try:

    “What information does this give me?”

    Perhaps the feedback identifies something in your practice you genuinely need to develop.

    Perhaps it shows that your reasoning was sound but your communication was unclear.

    Perhaps it reveals a difference in expectations that needs discussing.

    Perhaps, after reflection, you decide you would still make the same professional judgement.

    All of those outcomes are possible.

    The important thing is that you have considered the feedback rather than simply resisted it.

    Reflection

    Think about a recent piece of feedback that was difficult to hear.

    Ask yourself:

    1. What was actually said?
    2. What did I immediately think it meant about me?
    3. What part of the feedback was useful?
    4. Is there any context I still need to explain or clarify?
    5. What, if anything, will I do differently next time?

    Feedback becomes professionally useful when you can examine it without allowing one moment to become a verdict on your whole capability.

    The Core & Oak Perspective

    Being credible does not mean never being corrected.

    It does not mean defending every decision.

    And it does not mean automatically agreeing with whoever is more senior.

    Professional credibility includes being able to stay open when your judgement is challenged.

    Sometimes feedback will confirm something you already suspected.

    Sometimes it will reveal something you had not noticed.

    Sometimes you will decide, after thinking carefully, that you would still make the same decision.

    What matters is that you can listen, understand, evaluate and respond.

    Being trustworthy does not require you to be beyond challenge.

    It requires you to be capable of learning from it.

    Want more practical guidance for early professional practice?

    Core & Oak explores the parts of healthcare practice that are often expected but rarely explained clearly — professional judgement, communication, uncertainty and the hidden curriculum of becoming a trusted practitioner.

    Join the Core & Oak mailing list for new articles and practical resources.

    Continue exploring early practice

    If explaining your thinking when somebody questions it feels difficult

    How to Explain Your Clinical Reasoning Clearly as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional →

    Learn how to make the reasoning behind your decisions easier for other people to understand.

    If feedback quickly makes you question whether you belong

    Why Do New Healthcare Professionals Often Feel Like Imposters? →

    Explore why increasing responsibility can make capable early-career professionals feel less confident rather than more.

    If uncertainty itself is making it difficult to make decisions

    Confidence as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional: Safe Practice Without Certainty →

    Explore how safe professional judgement can still be possible when complete certainty is unavailable.

    Want to develop these skills more systematically?

    Being able to explain your reasoning is one part of communicating confidently in professional practice.

    Professional Communication in Everyday Healthcare takes this further through realistic situations involving uncertainty, escalation, asking for support, difficult conversations, feedback and communicating under pressure.

    If you want a structured way to develop these capabilities rather than picking them up only through trial and error, the course provides approximately 10 hours of self-paced CPD designed specifically for early-career healthcare professionals.

    About the author

    Dr Michael McCluskey is a Chartered Physiotherapist and Senior Fellow of the Higher Education Academy, with experience across clinical practice, healthcare education, programme leadership, assessment and curriculum development.

    He founded Core & Oak to create evidence-informed professional development that makes the hidden expectations of healthcare practice clearer.

    Professional education disclaimer

    This article provides general professional education. It does not provide individual clinical, employment, legal or other professional advice.

    Healthcare professionals should follow the professional standards, policies and procedures relevant to their profession, role and organisation.

    Further Reading

    Hardavella G, Aamli-Gaagnat A, Saad N, Rousalova I, Sreter KB. How to give and receive 
feedback effectively. Breathe (Sheff). 2017 Dec;13(4):327-333. doi: 10.1183/20734735.009917. PMID: 29209427; PMCID: PMC5709796.

    Algiraigri AH. Ten tips for receiving feedback effectively in clinical practice. Med Educ Online. 2014 Jul 28;19:25141. doi: 10.3402/meo.v19.25141. PMID: 25079664; PMCID: PMC4116619.

  • How to ask for help without feeling incompetent

    How to ask for help without feeling incompetent

    It is not usually the biggest decisions that make newly qualified healthcare professionals hesitate.

    It is the smaller moments.

    The patient whose observations do not quite fit the clinical picture. The wound that looks slightly different from yesterday. The medication calculation you have checked twice but still want someone else to review.

    You rehearse the question before approaching your supervisor.

    Everyone seems busy. You do not want to interrupt. You wonder whether you should already know the answer.

    Ten minutes later, you are still worrying.

    Eventually, you ask.

    Your supervisor listens, asks two questions and says:

    “I’m glad you came to ask.”

    The conversation lasts less than a minute.

    So why did asking feel harder than the question itself?

    In Brief

    Most newly qualified healthcare professionals do not ask too many questions.

    More often, they ask them too late.

    The goal is not to avoid asking for help. The goal is to ask well.

    Experienced clinicians do not expect you to know everything.

    They expect you to recognise uncertainty, organise your thinking and seek appropriate support when it matters.

    Those are all signs of developing professional judgement.

    Why does asking for help feel so difficult?

    Many newly qualified healthcare professionals assume they are being judged on what they know.

    That is understandable.

    Only a few months ago, your knowledge was being assessed through written exams, practical assessments and placement sign-offs. It can feel as though that judgement continues after qualification.

    In reality, something begins to change.

    Experienced clinicians are rarely expecting you to know everything.

    Instead, they notice how you respond when you are uncertain.

    Can you recognise that something doesn’t feel right?

    Can you explain why you are concerned?

    Can you seek help before uncertainty becomes risk?

    These behaviours often matter more than having the perfect answer.

    This is one of healthcare’s hidden expectations.

    Many of the qualities that help practitioners become trusted are never taught explicitly, but they are noticed every day.

    For some newly qualified professionals, this can also contribute to imposter feelings particularly when increasing knowledge makes you more aware of how much complexity there is in practice.

    Asking for help is part of professional judgement

    One of the biggest misconceptions in early practice is that asking for help signals a lack of competence.

    Most experienced clinicians see it differently.

    They are usually far more concerned about delayed escalation, misplaced confidence or silence than they are about thoughtful questions.

    Knowing when to involve someone else is part of safe practice.

    In fact, recognising your own uncertainty is often one of the clearest signs that your professional judgement is developing.

    That is a very different standard from “knowing everything”.

    Professional confidence is not the same as certainty; safe practice often depends on recognising uncertainty and responding to it appropriately.

    Core & Oak infographic showing the professional judgement cycle: recognise uncertainty, organise your thinking, ask well, act safely, reflect and grow.

    A simple way to organise your thinking before asking for help

    When you need support, the ASK Framework can help you organise your thinking before approaching a colleague.

    • Assess – What do I know? What am I uncertain about? Is anyone at immediate risk?
    • Structure – Briefly explain the situation, your concern, what you have already done and the decision you need help with.
    • Know your request – Be specific about the support you need.

    Not sure what to say in the moment?

    We’ve created a free practical guide for early-career healthcare professionals, with example language for asking for support, framing uncertainty and escalating concerns clearly.

    Get the free What to Say When You’re Unsure guide →

    Rather than asking:

    “Can you help?”

    try:

    “Could you help me decide whether this patient needs reviewing now?”

    Organising a question clearly often depends on being able to explain what you have noticed, what you think it means and why you are concerned. For more on that, read How to Explain Your Clinical Reasoning Clearly as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional.

    A worked example

    A newly qualified nurse noticed that a patient’s respiratory rate was gradually increasing.

    The patient appeared well, and the observations had not triggered an emergency response. Even so, something did not feel right.

    She asked a senior nurse to review the patient.

    The patient was later diagnosed with sepsis.

    The feedback she remembered was simple:

    “You did exactly the right thing.”

    She was not praised for knowing the diagnosis.

    She was praised for recognising uncertainty and acting on it.

    Reflection

    Think about the last time you hesitated before asking for help.

    • What stopped you?
    • Were you worried about interrupting?
    • Were you worried about looking inexperienced?
    • Were you worried about being wrong?
    • Or were you trying to protect your professional identity?

    Recognising these patterns is often the first step towards changing them.

    The Core & Oak Perspective

    The safest practitioners are not the ones who ask the fewest questions.

    They are the ones who recognise when a question needs asking.

    Over time, you will still ask for help. The questions will simply become more focused, more organised and more confident.

    Healthcare has never expected you to know everything.

    It expects you to recognise uncertainty, respond appropriately and seek support when it matters.

    Your Next step

    If this article resonated with you, you might also find these resources helpful:

    FREE RESOURCE

    What to Say When You’re Unsure

    A free practical guide with example language to help you:

    • raise a concern with a senior colleague
    • ask for support without simply saying “I don’t know”
    • explain what you’ve already considered
    • escalate when something doesn’t feel right

    Get the free guide →

    RELATED ARTICLE

    Why New Healthcare Professionals Feel Like Imposters

    You can know more than you did as a student and still feel less confident. Explore why increasing responsibility and awareness of complexity can make early practice feel unexpectedly difficult.

    Read the article →

    CONTINUE YOUR DEVELOPMENT

    Professional Communication in Everyday Healthcare

    If you want to develop these skills more systematically, this self-paced CPD course explores how communication, professional judgement and confidence come together in everyday healthcare practice.

    Across approximately 10 hours of learning, you’ll work through realistic situations involving uncertainty, difficult conversations, feedback, escalation and communicating under pressure.

    10 hours CPD · Self-paced · Designed for early-career healthcare professionals

    Continue exploring early practice

    If uncertainty and confidence are familiar themes, you may also find these useful:

    Confidence as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional: Safe Practice Without Certainty →
    Confidence does not mean having every answer. Explore what safe professional confidence looks like when uncertainty is part of everyday practice.

    How Much Anxiety Is Normal in a Newly Qualified Healthcare Role? →
    A practical way to think about anxiety, uncertainty and when a concern needs action.

    About the author

    Dr Michael McCluskey is a Chartered Physiotherapist and Senior Fellow of the Higher Education Academy, with experience across clinical practice, healthcare education, programme leadership, assessment and curriculum development.

    He founded Core & Oak to create evidence-informed professional development that makes the hidden expectations of healthcare practice clearer.

    Learn more about Michael and Core & Oak

    Professional education disclaimer

    This article provides general professional education. It does not provide individual clinical, employment, legal, psychological or occupational-health advice.

    Healthcare professionals should work within their scope of practice and follow the policies, escalation procedures and professional standards relevant to their role and organisation.

    Anyone experiencing significant or persistent distress should seek appropriate individual support.

    Editorial and evidence standards

    Core & Oak content is developed using the following principles:

    • content is written or reviewed by a suitably qualified professional;
    • professional and regulatory sources are prioritised where relevant;
    • research evidence is interpreted cautiously and within its limitations;
    • practical guidance is distinguished from individual clinical advice;
    • uncertainty, contextual variation and system pressures are acknowledged;
    • articles are periodically reviewed and updated;
    • commercial links are included only where the resource is relevant to the reader’s identified need.
  • Why Do New Healthcare Professionals Often Feel Like Imposters?

    Why Do New Healthcare Professionals Often Feel Like Imposters?

    You have completed the course, passed the assessments and met the requirements for professional registration.

    Other people now introduce you as the nurse, physiotherapist, pharmacist, occupational therapist, radiographer, doctor or healthcare professional responsible for someone’s care

    Yet part of you may still be waiting for someone to discover that you do not really know what you are doing.

    You may compare yourself with experienced colleagues who appear calm and certain. You may replay small mistakes after a shift, hesitate before asking for help or worry that needing reassurance means you are not ready for the role.

    You might think:

    • Everyone else seems more confident than me.
    • I should know this by now.
    • What if someone asks me something I cannot answer?
    • What if I make a mistake and people realise I am not capable?

    These thoughts can feel deeply personal.

    In reality, they often arise from a difficult but normal professional transition.

    You are no longer a student working within an educational safety net. You are now a registered professional expected to make, communicate and justify real decisions—often before you feel fully established in the role.

    That gap between being qualified and feeling like a credible practitioner is where imposter feelings often grow.

    In brief

    Newly qualified healthcare professionals often feel like imposters because their responsibility increases faster than their confidence and experience.

    Qualification confirms that you have met the standard required to enter professional practice. It does not mean that you will immediately feel comfortable in every situation or know how to respond to every unfamiliar presentation.

    Feeling uncertain does not automatically mean that you are unsafe.

    What matters is how you recognise risk, work within your limits, communicate concerns and seek appropriate support.

    Why imposter feelings are common after qualifying

    Responsibility changes quickly

    As a student, your work usually takes place within a visible structure of supervision, assessment and educational support.

    After qualification, supervision still exists, but it often feels less obvious. You may be expected to assess, plan, act, review, document and escalate while managing a real workload.

    You are simultaneously:

    • accountable for your own actions;
    • still developing professionally;
    • learning unfamiliar systems;
    • managing the needs of real patients;
    • being observed by colleagues;
    • working out what is expected but not always stated.

    This creates a difficult tension.

    You are expected to act as an autonomous practitioner, but you do not yet have the pattern recognition, contextual knowledge or confidence that develops through repeated experience.

    It can therefore feel as though you should know more than you do.

    The reality is simpler:

    Registration confirms readiness to begin professional practice. It does not mark the end of professional development.

    Healthcare is full of uncertainty

    Education can make practice appear more predictable than it is.

    Cases have learning outcomes. Assessments have marking criteria. Simulated scenarios are designed to test particular capabilities.

    Real practice is less tidy.

    Patients may present atypically. Information may be incomplete. Guidelines may not fit the person in front of you. Different professionals may interpret the same situation differently. Staffing, time and resources may also influence what is possible.

    A newly qualified practitioner may interpret this uncertainty as personal failure:

    “I do not know exactly what to do, so I must not be competent.”

    A more experienced practitioner is likely to ask:

    “What do I know, what is the immediate risk, what information is missing and who else needs to be involved?”

    The difference is not always knowledge.

    It is often a more developed way of managing uncertainty.

    You compare your internal doubts with other people’s external performance

    You hear your own uncertainty in full detail.

    You usually see only the visible behaviour of your colleagues.

    You see a senior nurse give a clear instruction, but not the years of experience behind it. You hear a consultant summarise a case confidently, but not every possibility they considered. You watch an experienced physiotherapist adapt an assessment, but not the many previous patients who helped them recognise the pattern.

    This creates an unfair comparison:

    your developing internal reasoning against someone else’s polished external performance.

    Experienced practitioners are not necessarily certain.

    They may simply be better at identifying priorities, organising uncertainty and communicating a clear plan.

    The hidden expectations are rarely explained

    Healthcare professionals are not judged only on whether they can complete clinical tasks.

    Colleagues also form impressions based on:

    • how you communicate when uncertain;
    • whether you recognise your limits;
    • how you respond to feedback;
    • whether you escalate appropriately;
    • how reliably you follow through;
    • whether you are safe to work alongside.

    Much of this assessment is informal and unspoken.

    This is part of the hidden curriculum of healthcare practice.

    When these expectations are not made explicit, newly qualified professionals may assume that credibility means appearing knowledgeable and confident at all times.

    It does not.

    Credibility is more often built through:

    • visible judgement;
    • clear communication;
    • appropriate humility;
    • consistent professional behaviour.

    Does uncertainty mean you are not competent?

    No.

    Feeling uncertain may indicate that you recognise the complexity of the situation.

    A new practitioner can feel anxious and still behave safely. An experienced practitioner can feel confident and still make a poor decision.

    The better question is not:

    “Do I feel confident?”

    It is:

    “Am I recognising risk, using the available information, working within my limits and seeking support when I need it?”

    Confidence and competence are related, but they are not the same. Professional confidence does not require complete certainty; it develops partly through learning how to respond appropriately when certainty is unavailable.

    Professional standards do not require you to know everything. They require you to work within your scope, recognise limitations and respond responsibly when you need advice or support.

    Asking for help is therefore not evidence that you are an imposter.

    It is part of safe professional practice.

    The important skill is learning how to ask in a way that makes your concern, reasoning and need for support clear.

    What people often misunderstand

    Asking for help does not automatically reduce credibility

    New practitioners sometimes delay asking for support because they fear being judged.

    In practice, senior colleagues usually need to know:

    • what has happened;
    • what you have observed;
    • what you have already considered or done;
    • what concerns you;
    • what support or decision you need.

    There is a difference between saying:

    “I do not know what to do.”

    and saying:

    “I am concerned about this change. I have checked the available information and I would like you to review it with me.”

    The second response does not pretend certainty.

    It demonstrates that you have engaged with the situation.

    One mistake does not prove that you should never have qualified

    Mistakes, omissions and imperfect decisions occur throughout professional life.

    What matters is how you respond.

    This includes:

    • addressing any immediate risk;
    • being open about what happened
    • seeking appropriate support;
    • learning from the situation;
    • identifying whether wider systems also need to change.

    One correction, one difficult shift or one piece of critical feedback does not invalidate your qualification.

    It gives you information about what you need to develop next.

    Confidence should not be the first goal

    Trying to feel confident at all times can encourage people to hide uncertainty or avoid asking questions.

    A safer early goal is to become increasingly able to:

    • recognise what matters;
    • explain your reasoning;
    • act within your limits;
    • escalate appropriately;
    • learn from experience.

    Confidence often follows repeated evidence that you can manage difficult situations safely.

    What safe practice looks like when you lack confidence

    Safe early-career practice does not mean performing like someone with ten years of experience.

    It means behaving appropriately for your current level of competence and responsibility.

    A safe and credible newly qualified practitioner:

    • notices and responds to risk;
    • works within their scope;
    • communicates concerns clearly;
    • asks focused questions;
    • documents important decisions;
    • responds openly to feedback;
    • becomes more independent over time.

    The aim is not to remove every feeling of uncertainty.

    The aim is to become increasingly capable of managing uncertainty safely.

    At this career stage, trust matters more than brilliance.

    A practical framework: NOTICE, FRAME, ACT

    When imposter feelings arise, use three steps.

    Three-step framework for responding to imposter feelings in healthcare practice: notice what you are uncertain about, frame what you know and need, then take a proportionate next step.

    NOTICE what is happening

    Separate the feeling from the professional situation.

    Ask yourself:

    • What am I uncertain about?
    • Is there an immediate patient-safety concern?
    • Is this outside my competence, or simply unfamiliar?
    • What information do I already have?
    • What information is missing?

    Instead of thinking:

    “I have no idea what I am doing.”

    Try to identify the specific issue:

    “I am uncertain whether this change is clinically significant, and I need to review the information and discuss it with a senior colleague.”

    The second statement is more precise and easier to act upon.

    FRAME the uncertainty professionally

    Organise what you need to communicate.

    A useful structure is:

    • Situation: What is happening?
    • Evidence: What have you observed?
    • Reasoning: What do you think may be happening?
    • Risk: What concerns you?
    • Request: What support or decision do you need?

    For example:

    “Mr Ahmed’s pain has increased over the last hour and he looks more pale than earlier. His blood pressure has also fallen compared with the previous reading. I am concerned this may represent more than expected postoperative pain. I have repeated his observations and would like you to review him now.”

    This does not claim certainty.

    It demonstrates attention, reasoning, risk recognition and appropriate escalation.

    ACT at the right level

    Choose a response proportionate to the situation.

    This may involve:

    • continuing with an appropriate plan;
    • checking a policy or guideline;
    • asking a focused question;
    • requesting supervision;
    • escalating urgently;
    • documenting the decision;
    • arranging review;
    • identifying a learning need afterwards.

    Once the situation is safe, reflect briefly:

    • What did I notice correctly?
    • What information changed the decision?
    • What would I recognise earlier next time?
    • What should I revise, practise or discuss?

    The purpose is not to prove that you were inadequate.

    It is to turn experience into better future judgement.

    Want to take stock of where your confidence is actually developing?

    Imposter feelings can make it easy to focus on what still feels difficult and overlook the professional capabilities you are already building.

    Our free Early-Career Communication Confidence Checklist can help you identify what already feels more comfortable, where you still hesitate and what you might want to strengthen next..

    Get the free Communication Confidence Checklist →

    Worked example

    A newly qualified physiotherapist is assessing a patient on an acute medical ward.

    The patient has been referred for a mobility assessment before discharge. During the assessment, the patient says they feel light-headed. The physiotherapist also notices that the patient appears less alert than they did at the beginning of the session.

    The physiotherapist thinks:

    “I should know whether this is serious. An experienced physiotherapist would know what to do. Perhaps I am overreacting.”

    An unsafe response would be to minimise the concern and continue because they do not want to appear inexperienced.

    An excessively dependent response would be to ask a senior colleague to take over without first identifying or communicating the concern.

    A safe and credible response would be to:

    • stop the assessment;
    • ensure the patient is safe;
    • clarify what has changed;
    • seek the appropriate clinical review;
    • communicate the concern clearly.

    The physiotherapist might say:

    “Mr Lewis became light-headed while standing and appears less alert than at the start of the assessment. I have stopped the session and returned him safely to the chair. I am concerned about the change in his presentation and do not think it is appropriate to continue until he has been reviewed.”

    The physiotherapist does not need to diagnose the cause.

    Their responsibility is to notice the change, stop safely, communicate clearly and involve the appropriate colleague.

    That is not evidence of being an imposter.

    It is professional judgement in action.

    Reflection and application

    Think about a recent situation in which you felt less capable than other people believed you were.

    Ask yourself:

    1. What was the specific professional uncertainty?
    2. What did safe practice require from me at that moment?
    3. What evidence suggests that I am developing?

    Evidence of development may include something you noticed, a question you asked, feedback you used, a concern you escalated or a decision you explained more clearly afterwards.

    You do not need to feel like an expert to behave like a responsible professional.

    When you may need additional support

    Imposter feelings should not be used to dismiss significant distress or difficult workplace conditions.

    Seek appropriate support if anxiety or self-doubt is:

    • affecting your sleep or life outside work;
    • making it difficult to attend work;
    • interfering with concentration or decision-making;
    • linked to bullying, discrimination or an unsafe workplace;
    • becoming difficult to manage alone.

    Support may be available from a trusted supervisor, line manager, preceptorship lead, professional body, occupational health service, trade union representative or healthcare professional.

    It is also important to recognise that not every confidence problem belongs to the individual.

    Poor induction, inconsistent supervision, excessive workload, incivility and psychologically unsafe team cultures can intensify imposter feelings.

    Healthcare organisations have a responsibility to create environments where staff can ask questions, discuss mistakes and raise concerns safely.

    The Core & Oak perspective

    Healthcare rewards more than the ability to complete tasks.

    Over time, practitioners become trusted because they can:

    • think through uncertainty;
    • communicate what matters;
    • justify decisions;
    • recognise limitations;
    • reflect on experience;
    • contribute safely within a team.

    You are not expected to arrive fully formed on the day you qualify.

    You are expected to practise responsibly while continuing to develop.

    The goal is not to manufacture confidence.

    It is to develop judgement that can be made visible, communicated clearly and defended professionally.

    That is how confidence becomes grounded in practice rather than performance.

    Your next step

    Clear communication is one of the main ways healthcare professionals make their judgement visible and Core & Oak resources can help with its development.

    FREE RESOURCE

    Early-Career Communication Confidence Checklist

    A practical self-review tool to help you identify:

    • useful priorities for your ongoing professional development
    • communication situations that already feel more comfortable
    • situations where you still hesitate
    • areas you may want to strengthen

    Get the free checklist→

    RELATED ARTICLE

    How much Anxiety is Normal in a Newly Qualified Health Role

    If uncertainty and self-doubt are becoming difficult to separate from normal early-career adjustment, explore how to recognise what your concern is asking you to do.

    Read the article →

    CONTINUE YOUR DEVELOPMENT

    Professional Communication in Everyday Healthcare

    If you want to develop these skills more systematically, this self-paced CPD course explores how communication, professional judgement and confidence come together in everyday healthcare practice.

    Across approximately 10 hours of learning, you’ll work through realistic situations involving uncertainty, difficult conversations, feedback, escalation and communicating under pressure.

    10 hours CPD · Self-paced · Designed for early-career healthcare professionals

    Continue exploring early practice

    Confidence as a Newly Qualified Healthcare Professional: Safe Practice Without Certainty →

    Explore what safe professional confidence looks like when you don’t have every answer and uncertainty remains part of practice.

    How to Ask for Help Without Feeling Incompetent →

    Learn how to organise your thinking and ask for support clearly when uncertainty means you need another person’s input.


    About the author

    Dr Michael McCluskey is a Chartered Physiotherapist and Senior Fellow of the Higher Education Academy, with experience across clinical practice, healthcare education, programme leadership, assessment and curriculum development.

    He founded Core & Oak to create evidence-informed professional development that makes the hidden expectations of healthcare practice clearer.

    Learn more about Michael and Core & Oak

    Professional education disclaimer

    This article provides general professional education. It does not provide individual clinical, employment, legal, psychological or occupational-health advice.

    Healthcare professionals should work within their scope of practice and follow the policies, escalation procedures and professional standards relevant to their role and organisation.

    Anyone experiencing significant or persistent distress should seek appropriate individual support.

    Editorial and evidence standards

    Core & Oak content is developed using the following principles:

    • content is written or reviewed by a suitably qualified professional;
    • professional and regulatory sources are prioritised where relevant;
    • research evidence is interpreted cautiously and within its limitations;
    • practical guidance is distinguished from individual clinical advice;
    • uncertainty, contextual variation and system pressures are acknowledged;
    • articles are periodically reviewed and updated;
    • commercial links are included only where the resource is relevant to the reader’s identified need.

    Sources and further reading

    Health and Care Professions Council. (2024) Standards of conduct, performance and ethics. Effective from 1 September 2024. London:HCPC.

    General Medical Council (2023) Good medical practice. Effective 30 Jan 2024. London: GMC. Available at: https://www.gmc-uk.org/professional-standards/good-medical-practice-2024. %5B1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

    Nursing and Midwifery Council. (2018). The code: Professional standards of practice and behaviour for nurses, midwives and nursing associates. NMC. https://www.nmc.org.uk/standards/code/ %5B1]

    Salari N, Hashemian SH, Hosseinian-Far A, Fallahi A, Heidarian P, Rasoulpoor S, Mohammadi M. Global prevalence of imposter syndrome in health service providers: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Psychol. 2025 May 28;13(1):571. doi: 10.1186/s40359-025-02898-4. PMID: 40437646; PMCID: PMC12117965.

    Chua SM, Tan IYK, Thummachai ME, et al. Impostor syndrome, associated factors and impact on well-being across medical undergraduates and postgraduate medical professionals: a scoping review. BMJ Open 2025;15:e097858. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-097858